Unanswered Questionsof OotP!!{SPOILER}

[Meg Boyd]

Okies, about Buckebeak... Have you read PoA twice? When I read that bit over again, it made more sense. I did understand it the first time properly, it just became a little clearer...

Prisoner of Azkaban wrote:
In the first 'time' this is what we are told...
There was a jumble of male vioces, a scilence and then, without warning, the unmistakable swish and thud of an axe.
(Then later on...)
Then, behind then, they heard a wild howling"
"Hagrid," Harry muttered.


Okies, later we learn that... After Harry and Hermoine take Buckbeak away, everyone in Hagrid's cabin comeo ut to witness the execution. They talk, wondering whre Buckbeak for to, (a jumble of male vioces). Mancair then swings the axe into the fence in anger, (the unmistakable swish and thud of an axe) Then, Hagrid yells out in joy that Buckbeak got away, (a wild howling)

ehhh...I still don't understand, where does it say that MacNair throws his axe in anger? I mean the thud of the ax could be the ax chopping buckbeak's head the howling Hagrid's tears...i am confused...and yes i have read PoA countless times, just not lately...

[Holly Golightly]

It says later, when we 'go back in time'... It's in the chapter titled Hermoine's Secret, and in my book, on page 294, about 1/2 way down...

[Meg Boyd]

ok, i'll check it when i go to work on Friday cause that's where my PoA is...its nice to have a job where i can read a lot...muhahahaha

[Holly Golightly]

hehehe! My copies of the series sit on my desk next to te puter, cause I always need to check something or other up while posting here!!!

(and on the rare occasion that I study, they get thrown on the floor! )

[Meg Boyd]

he he he...that's a good idea...perhaps I should do that, but since my father would prolly be furiousif I left my books lie about like that...my father is a clean freak, and all books if in the household must be on the shelf...he he he

[Holly Golightly]

hehehe! Well, in all honestly, my office is the messiest room in the house! The rest is clean, but no matter how many times I clean in here, it's always a mess! Must just be me!

I have put then away in the bookshelf a few times though, but it always seems that the next day, I want to find soemthing out, so back onto the desk they go!

[Eol]

About the time-turner, if Harry decides in the future that he wants to use it to rescue Sirius, then it would have all ready happened, just like in PoA when Harry thought he saw his dad save him with the Patronus but it turned out to be himself. So Sirius would already be saved innit!!!

[Holly Golightly]

Exactly Eol, and that is why they can't go back and save Sirius, becasue he never was saved!

It's one of those things that is kind of simple, yet at the same time, pretty confusing!