Broomsticks And Owls

by **Neo** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 5:21:17am

Well, it shuld be if both Voldemort and DD give the same explanation to what happened, it should be a ina book, so it must have happened before.

by **Holly Golightly** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 11:15:24am

Fake Moody told us that Harry was the only one... so how could it have happened before???

by **Neo** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 3:38:30am

Yeah, that's right. well he sais the only one they know, but maybe there is something about it, but they don't know who he/she was

by **Holly Golightly** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 9:00:35am

I don't kow.. DD seems to know everything, and you would think that if someone had evaded death, and as almost happened in the Harry-Voldie scenario, the spell rebounded and killed whoever was trying to do the killing, this imaginary person would be really rejoycing and go aroud telling people?

by **Neo** » Thursday 15 May 2003 5:41:32am

Yes, but maybe it was son long ago that it isn't in a book, and by now noone remembers.

by **Holly Golightly** » Friday 16 May 2003 8:36:07pm

Not very likely I think... wouldnt' they have wrote about it straight away, after all, when harry was in first yr, Hermoine said that he was in at least about three books already, and that was only 10yrs ago...

And if it's on a book, any book, wouldn't Hermoine have read it... *after all, she is a walkign library!!!!*

by **Neo** » Saturday 17 May 2003 6:40:48am

I knowm, if it were in a book we would know; but what if it happened 1000 years ago

by **Holly Golightly** » Saturday 17 May 2003 8:17:32am

they could still write then, couldn't they???

and I'd say even if they couldnt', it woudl be a pretty big revelation, so people woud remember and tell stories about it till they learnt to write? ie Myths and Legends!

by **Mistress Siana** » Monday 19 May 2003 2:15:25pm

I'd agree with Neo on that point...the way DD explained Harry how the incident could happen somehow left the impression that he was talking about a fact and not just an assumption.

by **Neo** » Monday 19 May 2003 5:17:03pm

Yeah; maybe DD has access to certain inforation or books, that others do not have and knows this kind of things; maybe he is heir of Godric and they pass a book that has all the wisdom known in the magic world, and since DD has no children (that we know) he will give it to Harry.

by **Holly Golightly** » Tuesday 20 May 2003 5:50:36am

Mistress Siana wrote:the way DD explained Harry how the incident could happen somehow left the impression that he was talking about a fact and not just an assumption.

DD said that "Unless I'm much mistken..." when he was talling harry about power transfer from Voldie.. sounds like someone who isn't totally postaive to me...

by **Mistress Siana** » Tuesday 20 May 2003 10:20:06am

Don't know...I usually say that phrase when I'm pretty sure of what I wanna say

by **Neo** » Tuesday 20 May 2003 9:18:46pm

He is not totally sure, but that is in first place that I said that it wasn't written in any book.

Besides, it seems that making books wasn't that popular 1000 years ago, I mean, in that case they should know when was Hogwarts constructed.

Broomsticks And Owls

GG's heir too predictable??

Who is online