Broomsticks And Owls

by **DarkSoul** » Saturday 3 September 2005 4:31:00pm

I have a theory that Snape's grude with Harry is more over the fact he defited the man that was meant to bring him to greatness more-over the fact that James is Harry's father.

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Sunday 30 October 2005 8:58:56am

Is there... anything else? Might be nice to give us a little evidence to support it or something. It's a bit of a good idea I suppose, but I still think it's just as likely after what we've seen, that he loathes Harry because of James.

by **SunsetG|rl** » Monday 31 October 2005 4:04:48pm

You're talking about what man? Lord Voldemort? He was the one supposed to bring Snape to glory? This ideea is a bit confusing... Or me too tired at this moment...

by **Chimera** » Thursday 15 December 2005 2:55:10pm

Voldemort was gonna bring nobody to glory. He's a loner and a user, his only concern about his associates is for their continued usefulness. If snape knew the first thing about Voldemort he'd know that much at least.

by **Broccoli** » Friday 16 December 2005 1:33:24am

Maybe he wanted to be the man who kills Voldemort! ;-)

This would surely lead him to glory... An unrealistic theory though I guess...

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Saturday 7 January 2006 10:27:54am

Not really too outrageous.

I'm not sure, but I think that's the sort of theory Tanuki has in mind, actually.
For Snape to be on his own side, watch Harry and Voldemort battle, and then try to destroy whatever remains. :-?

by **Bextra** » Friday 13 January 2006 10:59:57am

Wasn't Snape's grudge that James was everything Snape wanted to be? And then that hatred for James was soon passed on to Harry?

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Saturday 14 January 2006 9:51:10am

Yeah, we've sorta moved on from there a little bit.

But yes, that's pretty much what we're supposed to believe...

Broomsticks And Owls

What Is Snape's Grudge

What Is Snape's Grudge

Who is online