Broomsticks And Owls

by **honey moon** » Saturday 14 October 2006 5:55:23pm

i don't think he is evil
i think in the end it'll turn out that he is good...but i dunno how and when and why *grin*

by **Phinea Rogue** » Tuesday 17 October 2006 11:50:56am

In my opinion, he's on his own side, a typical Slytherin (neither truly evil, nor truly good). :grin:

by **Simatra** » Tuesday 17 October 2006 8:05:16pm

what if he was and he going to kill voldy and it turns out Snape was the Dark Lord all along? Wait... Dose that sound as stupid as I think It sounds? :???:

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Wednesday 18 October 2006 6:30:39am

Well, I'd say that the prophecy has basically established almost beyond doubt that Voldemort is the Dark Lord.. because he marked the child.

by **Simatra** » Wednesday 18 October 2006 8:20:55pm

Oh yeah, duh... *kicks myself in the head*

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Thursday 19 October 2006 6:02:08am

Not necessarily.. it doesn't mean that Snape doesn't think he's the Dark Lord, because remember he didn't hear the entire prophecy when he eavesdropped.

So he might not have heard the bit about marking the child as an equal.. and thus thinks he has the power to become the true Dark Lord.

by **Simatra** » Thursday 19 October 2006 3:51:26pm

You made me feel stupid all over again! Stop making me feel stupid!

by **Alexandra** » Saturday 28 October 2006 9:25:46pm

He is not evil. Something happened to him to change sides and I still can't figure out what is that!!! Maybe he was deeply in loved with some girl/boy and L.V. hurt her/him. Maybe they hurt someone from his family, a mother, father... But J.K. has that kind of style that it will be a dog or a cat or some kind of mutant.... :???:

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Sunday 29 October 2006 3:15:46am

Sorry Simatra!

Hmm, or maybe he was never that evil. Just cruel and lonely.

by **Alexandra** » Sunday 29 October 2006 11:00:55pm

I think James and his friends pushed a little too hard... Maybe one part of the blame is on James. Maybe if he didn't torture Snape so hard it wouldn't be like that. But maybe it would be the same, who knows? :-?

by **Simatra** » Monday 30 October 2006 8:48:39pm

This 7th book is going to be HUGE!

" Reports are saying that HP7 is the biggest book known to mankind... is 5,000,000 words longer than an unibridged dicionary... readers still are unimpressed..."

by **Alexandra** » Thursday 2 November 2006 12:39:35am

You're kidding, right??

by **Simatra** » Thursday 2 November 2006 8:39:10pm

No, I'm dead serious.

( Yes, I'm joking. It would take me awhile to read that!

)

by **Alexandra** » Friday 3 November 2006 1:23:55am

Now yopu made me sad! :cry:

The bigger book it is the more explanations we get. But she could never write book as big as that!

by **Phoenix in the Ashes** » Friday 3 November 2006 7:18:43am

I want it to be OoTP length.. but I don't think it will be.

Anyway, isn't this a discussion on Snape?

Broomsticks And Owls

Is Snape Evil?

Who is online