Broomsticks And Owls

by **Simatra** » Wednesday 27 December 2006 6:59:05pm

Snape is too evil! You can't kill someone and not be evil!!

by **Alexandra** » Thursday 28 December 2006 1:10:38am

But what if he killed DD to save the mankind?

by **youknowwho** » Thursday 28 December 2006 8:38:32pm

Alexandra wrote:But what if he killed DD to save the mankind?

I have a theory about that, Dumbledore and voldemort are opposite characters so by Killing Dumbledore Snape proves that Voldemort can be killed as well.

by **Alexandra** » Friday 29 December 2006 2:17:15am

I think it's silly to kill Dumbledore only because of that but I think that, when Harry first herd Dumbledore begging that night, I think he begged Snape to kill him. I am not sure about Snape's face although, maybe he didn't agree with Dumbledore's decision but he still murdered him or something like that.

by **Simatra** » Tuesday 2 January 2007 5:21:28pm

You know, it dosen't really matter to Harry if he's evil or not, now dose it? He's never really liked Snape, and now he's killed DD. If Snapes good or not Harry still not going to like him.
Hermy: No harry Snapes a good guy! I've figered it out! (she explains it all.)
Harry: Oh, well in that case, I'm going to forgive him for anything and everything he ever did to me.
^ That dosen't sound like Harry to me! :-)

by **Alexandra** » Thursday 4 January 2007 10:08:11pm

I never thought that Harry will ever forgive Snape, I was just wondering why did Snape killed DD.

by **Simatra** » Friday 5 January 2007 8:00:40pm

Not directing it towards you. It's just what I think.

by **Alexandra** » Monday 22 January 2007 12:37:40am

So thats it, he is not evil! He is just... Complicated to understand, thats all!

by **Simatra** » Tuesday 23 January 2007 10:57:28pm

Anyone who kills someone HAS to be complicated!

by **Alexandra** » Thursday 1 February 2007 11:20:37pm

I agree but i think he had some arrangement with DD. I think that, when DD begged, DD actually begged Snape to kill him and thats why he had that look on his face. Snape didn't want to do it but he knew he had to!