What Doesn't Harry Know?

[Neo]

Yeah, I know it is more likely to be Snape, and based on the plot will be more obvious, but that0s what Jo bases HP books, in writing things that seem clear, and result not

[Holly Golightly]

Yeah, I suppose, but then nothing in the books has really given off the hint that there was ever anything between Snape and Lily, that's just something that we have all guessed might be possible due to way too much analysis!!!

[MikeT]

Please visit:

http://www.broomsticksandowls.com/forum ... .php?t=906

To read my whole big theory!

[Neo]

Yeah I know, everyone is wondering and thinking if Snape was in love with Lily or something like that; but why I'm almost sure of is that Voldemort has some connection with Lily (I'm not sure which), so I have write most of them already in this forum. But certainly Snapes theory fits better in the world so far we know.

[Holly Golightly]

I read your theory, and I like it alot!!

Also, I just can't see Voldie as being hte one who was in love with Lily... actually, I can't really see Voldie being in love with anyone but himself and power!!! After all, he's the evil one...

hehehe, I think that smilie is kinda cute in a nasty way!!!
*yes, I know, I'm strange!!!*

[Hermione]

I think that people who think Voldemort/Snape was in love with Lily have been reading far too many fanfics.

[Neo]

Well actually I haven't read any fan fic, but I have a lot of imagination, and I think that Voldemort being Harry's grandfather would be cool (it sounds like Star Wars, but no that much as if he was his father), or myabe only the uncle, or something, they've got to be related in a way (that's what I think, I'm a little weird too)

[Holly Golightly]

Yeah, I agree, you are a bit weird Neo...

*points at Neo* Weirdo!!!

(only joking Neo!!!)

I dont' think that they will be related. I think that they already have enough connections, the scar, the blood, the power transfer.... Yeah, I definately think that's enough!!!

[Neo]

I know, by now there are several connections, but why if the connection was because they are related in someway plus the love of Lily to protect Harry. I mean the curse even if ti was blocked didn't have to give Harry some of Voldemorts things (like Parsel), maybe that is part of being related.

[Holly Golightly]

It could be I suppose, becuase DD didtn'say that it was the failed curse that definately gave Harry parseltounge etc, just that it was his theory that it did...

Oh, but then I would assume that DD would know if Voldie was relatedt o harrry by blood... he knows everything else after all..

But maybe he's lying about it to protect Harry fromt he knoweldge...

Uhh, but then DD has never really lied to harry... he hasnt't old him stuff before, but never lied...

*uhhh, having big debate in my own head... maybe I should stop it now!!! *

I still think no, harry is not related to Voldie by blood!

[Neo]

I think that if it happens to exist the blood relation, DD doesn't know about it.

[Holly Golightly]

Well, he couldn't... otherwise why would he have told Harry that he thinks that the similarities are due to the curse thing? He just wouldn't have answered if he knew the truth...

[Neo]

That's my point, so maybe Jo will surprise all of us with that (and maybe even the same DD)

[Holly Golightly]

I just though of another possibility for what Harry doesn't know...

Maybe it's not something about his mother, like we have been seeming to think... *or at least I have!!!*

Maybe it's about the person who gets powers... ie, Harry, I should ahve told you this 5yrs ago... your cousin Dudley is a wizard too!!! * *


(Okies, I really don't think that this will happen, but I was trying to think of another possibility for what he didnt' know!!!* )

[Neo]

Lol, tat woyuld be very very weird; but hey it could be, Jo said that someone is going to develop magic abilities later in life (it could be dudley); but wait in that case DD woulnd't have know it five years ago. (So apparently we will know about Lily and James)