Harry Potter vs. Twilght ***SPOILERS***

[*Riley*]

I thought The Host was an auto-biography, or a non-fiction novel.
Also guys, try not to spoil anything; it's getting a bit deep for anyone who would like to read it

[FawkesthePhoenix]

Melanie's much cooler.

Agreed. And when Wanda got a new body...I just thought that was so stupid!

I agree, what and inconclusive ending it had!

You're right, Riley, perhaps we should keep the spoiler-laden conversation to PMs.

I think that Stephenie Meyer should've made Bella more independant. If you think about it, the books don't really set that great of an example. In New Moon, Bella completely lets herself go, contemplating suicide and becoming anti-social. And this is supposed to be romantic. In Breaking Dawn,) Bella gets married and pregnant just out of high school. But there aren't any bad consequences, oh no, everything turns out perfectly, creating a "wonderful love story". Anyone else see what's wrong with this picture. This is essentially why Twilight has steadily lost its appeal to me. It's an okay series, but it in no way approaches the awesomeness of Harry Potter.

[DucksRMagical]

Well, she was married when she got pregnant, so I don't really see the whole pregnancy thing as an issue. If she got pregnant in high school before she was married, then I'd see a problem. But she was legally an adult, married, and in love. Yeah, she was kind of young, but plenty of people get married young and it works out fine. Then there are people who get married when they're older and it ends in divorce.

But I do get what you are saying about New Moon, Fawkes. Bella isn't really a good role model.

[Scellanis]

I think its a bit late to save this from spoilers so I have edited the original post title to warn people the thread contains spoilers, you can now carry on with your full of spoilers discussion.

[hprocks]

your right about the whole marrige thing my brother got
married at24 so now i have a sister in law. he got married on valentines day of last year


hprocks

[*Riley*]

So many spoilers... my stupidity for coming in here... *Sigh*
I am trying to find Eclipse but now know that Bella has a child via some weird demon thing and then gets married. Her daighters name is Renesmee and Jacob falls in love with her.. Ahk! I hope there is more twists I don't know..

[DucksRMagical]

I loved The Host. I loved it more than Twilight. I came to this thread before I finished it, though, so I knew the ending when I was only halfway through the book. But I still enjoyed it.

[FawkesthePhoenix]

So many spoilers... my stupidity for coming in here... *Sigh*
I am trying to find Eclipse but now know that Bella has a child via some weird demon thing and then gets married. Her daighters name is Renesmee and Jacob falls in love with her.. Ahk! I hope there is more twists I don't know..

Don't worry Riley, I don't think it's even possible to spoil every twist in Breaking Dawn.

[Albus Severus Potter]

first things first, I think that HP is better than Twilight and always will be.
Also without all the hype from the 7th book and the 6th movie Twilight would never have been so popular

[FawkesthePhoenix]

What do you mean? I don't quite understand what you're saying.

[Albus Severus Potter]

I mean without Harry Potter, Twilight would not be as popular

[hprocks]

um...... what do you mean without harry potter twighlight woundn't be so popular

do you mean that with out j.k. rowlings magical world twighlight wouldn't exsist?

[Ms. Elsewhere]

Woo hoo! I have just discovered Stephanie Meyer... and I LOVE IT! But.. I have only read Twilight and have just started New Moon. So. I did not read anything else in here after I started seeing things about someone getting married young. Thank heavens I didn't accidently see who she married!

Right, so I have to say, HP forever! Twilight is awesome, but HP has a lot more depth, and has so many little subplots and characters. So far the 'human' characters in this series are relatively shallow, and I'm dying to see what happens with Mike... Edward did say "He's getting on my nerves." I'm not hoping for much though.. just enjoying the ride! But I expect you all know.. so I"m not ASKING i'm just wondering.

Oh! and soooooooooooooon the Potter movie 6 will be out.... so we'll have heaps to talk about then. I haven't seen Twilight either.. out over here on April 22...... *so excited*.

xx

[hprocks]

i was wondering if anyone knows any online book sites that i can read the eclipse by stephanie meyer

[Ms. Elsewhere]

As well.. I've heard that she is not going to release Midnight Sun now that it has leaked on the internet! So does that mean it's ok to read it now? I'm not sure about online book sites.. never had the opportunity to look.. would be interested to know how they work.. do u subscribe?

xx