Broomsticks And Owls

by **MikeT** » Saturday 10 May 2003 9:16:32am

yeah definatly...and I suppose Lily could be the "special fan" too...

cuz parents always call their child "champ" or something like that....

This would surprise a lot of people.....if this were to happen........An thnk of the potential in the films! The flashback......scary!

(p.s I posted this tyhoery on the MPZ Comments, on the "Comment of the Day")

by **Neo** » Sunday 11 May 2003 6:11:53am

About Lily being the special fan, I'm not sure because then what about James (I mean both died trying to protect Harry).
But if we see Lili'y dead for the movies it will be excellent, with a gloomy atmosphere at the beggining, (change of camera to see Sirius realizing the mstake he has donde) return to Godric's Hollow and Voldemort entering the door, and James waiting for him.

by **MikeT** » Sunday 11 May 2003 9:00:25am

I know that, but he could have more than one special fan. Because this topic is about Lily dying, then its not gunna be about James too...Sure J could be Harry's special fan. But i think it'll be Lily who we see dead!

by **Neo** » Monday 12 May 2003 4:21:20am

I think that the death of Lily appearig in the book is very likely, but the death of the "special" fan will be another.

by **Holly Golightly** » Monday 12 May 2003 7:51:21am

Lily's death does have alot more intrigue about it than James's, doesn't it??? And I'ms till not sure if I think that Lily will be the only death as such, or if there will be another... I am leaning towards anohter death though...

It just doesnt' seem like it willbe quite as bad as JK seems to have insinuated if it was only Lily's death that she was talking about...
Just a hunch I suppose... :-?

by **Neo** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 5:41:51am

I think we will see two deaths, but Lily's won't be the one hard to write, because this reason she gave I think it will be Hagrid.

by **Holly Golightly** » Tuesday 13 May 2003 11:31:23am

Yes, I think that there is a good chance that it is Hagrid...

I mean, his role has kind of finished really... apart from still being a friend. He introduced Harry to Hogwarts, but now he's used to it...

Okies, that's not explaining what I mean very well, but maybe you can see where I'm coming from??

by **Neo** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 3:44:37am

Moreless; you mean that Hagrig won't be that important in the next books; I don't know it seems he went to search for the giants, taht si very important (what if he is killed by his mother?, that surely is hard writing)

by **Holly Golightly** » Wednesday 14 May 2003 9:06:29am

Damn it, I totally forgot about that!

*Sometimes, I remind myself of Mint! hehehe*

Wait.. maybe the giants will immediately kill Hargid, but for some reason listen to Madam Maxine...
*they are very unpredicatle and brutal after all... *

Okay, I don't really think that it will happen, but it's a theory after all! So do tell me what you think of it!

by **Neo** » Thursday 15 May 2003 5:46:33am

I don0't think they will kill Hagrid the first time the see him. Maybe Madame and him go again in Easter Holidays, and in that time Hagrid is killed (it sounds more probable, to me)

by **Holly Golightly** » Thursday 15 May 2003 5:52:17am

Well,I really dont' think that the giants will kill Hagrid at all, it was jsut an idea!

What if maybe there is some kind of fight between the giants *who I guess go to DD's side* and something or other from Voldie's side...and Hagrid gets killed during it...

Or, what if Voldie just knows that DD and harry are good friends with Hagrid and decide to have him offfed to make them suffer... After all, Voldie really does seem to lke killing people!

Or, he decided to Kill Hagrid because he's not a pureblood wizard?? *Voldie decided by the way*

:???:

by **Neo** » Thursday 15 May 2003 6:21:32am

It could be, but I'm not sure why he would go directly to attack Hagrid.

About the giants fight, that sounds very probable (maybe the part whwre Hagrid is killed no, but the fight yes); and Hagrid tries to talk with the giants that side with Voldemrt and they kill him.

by **Holly Golightly** » Thursday 15 May 2003 8:24:52am

[quote="Neo"]It could be, but I'm not sure why he would go directly to attack Hagrid[quote]

To make DD and Harry suffer... maybe Barty Jr told Voldie that Harry is really good friends with Hagrid?

by **Neo** » Thursday 15 May 2003 8:33:30am

Well, he could have done it; still he could kill Ron, or Hermione, no?

by **Holly Golightly** » Thursday 15 May 2003 8:40:52am

I suppose that he could...

I just think that hagrid is going to die, and I am looking for reasons for it!

Broomsticks And Owls

My Theory (with help of Kim) - The Person To Die Is......

Who is online