What if Dumbledore told Harry the truth...

What would have happened if The Sorting Hat had insisted on sorting Harry into Slytherin? Or what if Harry had become friends with Draco Malfoy instead of Ron during their first journey on the Hogwarts Express? Wander into alternative Harry Potter universes here.

Moderators: Run Away!!!, Un'Anima Persa, *Riley*

What if Dumbledore told Harry the truth...

Postby AngelicS_89 » Monday 1 March 2004 11:41:46pm

I was reading the part with Sirius's death and I thought what if Dumbledore told Harry the truth about the prophecy?

Would Sirius die?How would Harry live with a thought that he will have to kill somebody or be murdered himself?Would everything stay the same or some things would change?Dumbledore knew the whole prophecy and he knew that or Harry or Neville are the one who will destroy LV,what if he warned Potters and Longbottoms?Would Potters be dead,would Harry be famous?
User avatar
AngelicS_89
Keeper of Smiles and Happiness
 
Posts: 1255
Joined: Wednesday 24 December 2003 7:04:02pm
Location: heaven

Postby Gower » Monday 1 March 2004 11:51:28pm

It might have been too late to warn the Longbottoms when he first found out about the prophecy. They might have already been insane by then. I'm sure he did warn the Potters, which is why Lily wanted to protect Harry so much, even to die for him.
User avatar
Gower
Gryffindor Prefect, Head of Gryffindor Security Force and Member of Hogwarts Chess Team
 
Posts: 1429
Joined: Monday 8 September 2003 11:02:54pm

Postby Cruzio » Tuesday 2 March 2004 4:25:26pm

It might have been too late to warn the Longbottoms when he first found out about the prophecy. They might have already been insane by then.

Well they were tortured for information about Voldemorts whereabouts by bellatrix & CO, so that would be after LV had lost his powers. And for the Potters to have been warned the prophecy would have had to occure prior to that.
So if the Potters were warned, I'm quite sure the Longbottoms were aswell.
Cruzio
Third Year Student in Witchcraft and Wizardry
 
Posts: 44
Joined: Saturday 28 February 2004 11:07:36pm

Postby Moonstone » Tuesday 20 April 2004 11:43:30am

And it i´n´t good to tell a prophesy to some one.. because it can backfier totaly and the more imprten ppl that are supposed to kill the evil can be killed by misstake.. and we dont want that...do we??
User avatar
Moonstone
Fully Qualified Wizard
 
Posts: 394
Joined: Wednesday 14 April 2004 1:45:32pm
Location: Leving the milkbottle and heading out into the big scary world

Postby harrylover » Tuesday 15 June 2004 7:44:37pm

i think if dumbledor would have told harry sirius wouldn´t be dead...harry would know what was in the ministry and he would have known that voldemort would try and get him there...
User avatar
harrylover
Queen of Gossip and Member of Dumbledore´s Army
 
Posts: 1478
Joined: Saturday 14 February 2004 11:49:34am


Return to What If?

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

cron